Call us:  0800 0 224 224

Our claims services

More from Thompsons

Contact us today

Call us free on

0800 0 224 224

Email us at

enquiries@thompsons.law

Contact one of our offices

Find your local office

The EAT considered whether an employee who had been redeployed to another part of the business as a reasonable adjustment was assigned to it when it transferred

Employment Law Review 13 November 2026

 

By Brian Wilson Member, Employment Rights Manager

Mr K P McConnell had worked for WM Morrisons Supermarkets Ltd since May 2000, latterly at its Stockton-on-Tees distribution centre. Following an accident in 2010, he developed a disabling back condition, and it was accepted that he was disabled for the purposes of the Equality Act 2010. 

In 2017, Mr McConnell began working part-time in the Returns & Recycling Unit (RRU), while retaining his contractual role in the Ambient warehouse. Following occupational health advice, Morrisons moved him permanently to the RRU in 2020. The advice suggested that he would benefit from working there because he could not undertake picking duties, and driving forklift trucks in the Ambient warehouse risked jarring his back. 

However, following changes to working practices in the RRU, recycling and waste increasingly arrived in wheeled metal cages rather than on pallets. This meant employees had to push and pull the cages manually. Mr McConnell maintained that this aggravated his back condition and caused him pain, and argued that forklift work in the Ambient warehouse was more suitable because it involved less manual handling. 

In January 2023, Morrisons announced that the RRU operation would be outsourced and would transfer under the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations 2006 (TUPE). Mr McConnell had spent 100% of his working time in the RRU during the previous 26 weeks and was therefore identified as assigned to the part of the business transferring. Concerned about what the transfer would mean for his employment and existing restrictions, he formally objected, and his employment ended on the transfer date. 

Mr McConnell brought a number of claims, including indirect disability discrimination, failure to make reasonable adjustments and victimisation. He also challenged whether he had been properly assigned to the transferring undertaking for TUPE purposes. The Employment Tribunal dismissed his claims and Mr McConnell appealed. 

 

Outcome 

The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the appeal in part. 

The EAT rejected Mr McConnell's challenge to the finding that he had been assigned to the RRU for TUPE purposes. It held that there is no rigid formula for determining whether an employee is assigned to an organised grouping which transfers. Although the percentage of time spent working in a particular part of a business can be relevant, it is not itself the legal test. In this case, Mr McConnell had worked permanently and exclusively in the RRU for more than two years, and the tribunal had been entitled to conclude that he was assigned to it. 

Importantly, the EAT held that the lawfulness of the circumstances which led to an employee working in a particular department is separate from the factual question of whether they are assigned to it for TUPE purposes. Even if an employee argues that their placement resulted from discrimination or victimisation, that does not necessarily prevent them from being assigned to the transferring undertaking. 

However, the EAT found that the tribunal had gone wrong in its consideration of Mr McConnell's indirect discrimination and reasonable adjustments claims. The tribunal had identified the relevant provision, criterion or practice (PCP) as "tipping" trailers and had found that this placed people with Mr McConnell's disability at a particular disadvantage by increasing pain and tiredness. But it then failed properly to connect the pushing and pulling of cages, which was part of the tipping process in the RRU, with that identified disadvantage. 

The EAT also held that the tribunal had wrongly brought Morrisons' knowledge of the disadvantage into its assessment of indirect discrimination. Unlike a reasonable adjustments claim, an indirect discrimination claim under section 19 of the Equality Act 2010 does not require the employer to know that its practice is putting the claimant at a disadvantage. 

The tribunal had also failed adequately to consider whether there were reasonable alternatives to Mr McConnell remaining in the RRU. Its reliance on occupational health advice ruling out a return to the Ambient warehouse did not resolve the issue, particularly as Mr McConnell's case was that there may have been other suitable areas in which he could work. 

Although the EAT identified an error in the tribunal's approach to Mr McConnell's victimisation claim, including its inappropriate reference to him having "affirmed" the alleged treatment, it upheld the ultimate dismissal of that claim. The tribunal had made a sufficient finding that his earlier grievance alleging disability discrimination was not the reason for Morrisons' treatment of him. 

The indirect discrimination and reasonable adjustments claims, together with the associated question of time limits, were therefore remitted to a freshly constituted Employment Tribunal for reconsideration. 

 

Comments / Key takeaways 

This judgment is an important reminder that tribunals must identify precisely what it is about a workplace practice that places a disabled worker at a disadvantage. It is not enough simply to identify a broad PCP and then consider the worker's individual duties separately. Where those duties form part of the practice complained of, their real-world effect on the worker must form part of the assessment. 

The case also reinforces the distinction between indirect discrimination and the duty to make reasonable adjustments. An employer's knowledge of disability and disadvantage is relevant to the reasonable adjustments duty, but knowledge of the discriminatory effect of a PCP is not a requirement for establishing indirect discrimination under section 19 of the Equality Act 2010. It may, however, be relevant when an employer seeks to justify the PCP. 

For employers, the decision highlights the risks of treating occupational health advice as the end of the reasonable adjustments process. If an existing arrangement is causing a disabled worker substantial disadvantage, the question is not simply whether one particular alternative has been ruled out. Employers should consider the range of potentially reasonable steps available, including alternative duties or working arrangements where appropriate. 

For trade unions and workplace representatives, the case underlines the importance of clearly documenting how particular duties and working practices affect a disabled member. When challenging a workplace practice, representatives should identify both the PCP and the practical tasks within it that create the disadvantage, as well as setting out potential adjustments that might remove or reduce it. 

The TUPE aspect of the judgment is also significant. The EAT confirmed that the question of assignment is fundamentally a factual one. The amount of time an employee spends within a transferring part of a business can be relevant, but there is no automatic percentage test. Equally, an allegation that an employee was placed within that part of the business unlawfully does not, by itself, determine whether they were assigned to it when the transfer took place. 

Mr K P McConnell v WM Morrisons Supermarkets Ltd [2026] EAT 149Â