Â
By Chloe Jasper, Employment Rights Lawyer
Â
Background
Mathios Berhane began working for Adebowale Olujimi and Olugbesoye Olujimi in October 2020 as a driver and personal assistant. He initially worked under fixed-term contracts and the respondents accepted that he was an employee up to 30 April 2022.
In April 2022, the respondents gave notice to terminate his employment, with his fixed-term contract ending on 30 April. From 1 May, a new arrangement took effect under which Berhane worked on a zero-hours basis and was paid £150 for each day worked rather than receiving a monthly salary.
In an email shortly before the new arrangement began, Berhane acknowledged that the respondents would not be obliged to offer him work and that he would not be obliged to accept work when offered. The arrangement was later brought to an end, and he was sent a P45 on 19 July 2022.
Berhane subsequently brought a number of claims, including automatic unfair dismissal under section 104 of the Employment Rights Act 1996. He alleged that he had been dismissed after asserting a statutory right to paid holiday on 22 April 2022. He also brought claims for notice pay, unlawful deductions from wages and breach of contract, alongside discrimination claims.
The Employment Tribunal struck out the automatic unfair dismissal claim as being out of time, treating 30 April 2022 as the effective date of termination. It also struck out the notice pay claim, finding that Berhane was no longer an employee by the time the later zero-hours arrangement ended. His discrimination claims were allowed to proceed to a full hearing.
Berhane appealed, arguing that the tribunal had been wrong to treat 30 April as the effective date of termination without properly determining whether his employment had continued, albeit on different terms, until July 2022. If his employment had continued until July, his automatic unfair dismissal claim would have been brought within the applicable time limit once the ACAS early conciliation provisions were taken into account.
Outcome
The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) dismissed the appeal.
The EAT held that the Employment Tribunal had been entitled to proceed on the basis that Berhane's employment ended on 30 April 2022. Importantly, a definitive list of issues had been agreed following three case management hearings. That list expressly identified 30 April as the date of dismissal for the automatic unfair dismissal claim and described the subsequent arrangement as a re-engagement on a zero-hours contract.
The EAT said that, in those circumstances, the tribunal was entitled to decide the strike-out application on the basis of the case set out in the agreed list of issues. Any departure from that position would have required a formal amendment, reconsideration or appeal.
The EAT also found that the Employment Tribunal had, in any event, considered Berhane's employment status after 30 April. It was entitled to conclude that there was no reasonable prospect of him establishing that he remained an employee after that date because the new arrangement lacked mutuality of obligation, an essential feature of a contract of employment. The respondents were under no obligation to offer work and Berhane was under no obligation to accept it.
The EAT considered this to be a fundamental change in the parties' relationship rather than simply a variation to the existing employment contract. Berhane therefore ceased to be an employee on 30 April and became a worker under the new arrangement. His automatic unfair dismissal claim was consequently out of time.
Although the Employment Tribunal's reasoning elsewhere in its judgment contained some confusion about whether his employment status remained an issue for the discrimination claims, the EAT concluded that this did not undermine the decision on the automatic unfair dismissal claim. There had been no material error of law and the appeal was dismissed.
Comments / Key takeaways
This judgment is a useful reminder of the importance of employment status, mutuality of obligation and carefully defined lists of issues in tribunal proceedings.
For workers moving from conventional employment onto zero-hours or casual arrangements, a change in contractual terms can amount to more than a simple variation of the existing employment relationship. Where there is no longer an obligation on the employer to provide work, or on the individual to accept it, this may indicate that employee status has ended, even where the working relationship itself continues.
The case also highlights the importance of lists of issues in Employment Tribunal proceedings. Once the issues have been carefully considered and finalised through case management, a tribunal will generally be entitled to decide the case on that basis. A party who later wants to advance a materially different case may need to seek a formal amendment or challenge the earlier case management decision.
For trade unions and workplace representatives, the judgment highlights the need to look carefully at any proposed move from permanent or fixed-term employment to zero-hours, casual or other forms of working. The label attached to an arrangement is not, by itself, decisive. The practical obligations between the parties, including whether work must be offered and accepted, can be central to determining employment status and the statutory rights that follow from it.
Mathios Berhane v Adebowale Olujimi and Olugbesoye Olujimi [2026] EAT 109.      Â